Blog Books

From Harry Potter to Thomas Aquinas [VIDEO #3] | Brandon Vogt

From Harry Potter to Thomas Aquinas [VIDEO #3] | Brandon Vogt

NOTE: That is Video #three in my new 5-part collection “Why It’s Time for a Catholic Dumbledore’s Military (and Why You Have to Be a part of)”! Watch the video above or learn the transcript under. And signal as much as get the remainder of the movies at!


Welcome again to this free video collection on “Why It’s Time for a Catholic Dumbledore’s Military (and Why You Have to Be a part of)”!

Once more, I’m Brandon Vogt, bestselling writer of seven books, together with Why I Am Catholic and RETURN. I additionally work for Bishop Robert Barron’s Phrase on Hearth Catholic Ministries.

Let’s shortly recap what we discovered within the first couple movies (and by the best way, for those who missed any earlier movies, simply click on the movies on this web page to return and watch.)

In Video #1, we discovered how Harry Potter saved Hogwarts and all the wizarding world. Keep in mind that? He created Dumbledore’s Military, this rag-tag group of scholars of taught themselves the sensible expertise they weren’t getting from their academics.

Then in Video #2, the final video, we discovered 5 the reason why we Catholics ought to imitate this plan, why we’d like a Catholic Dumbledore’s Military since we discover ourselves in the identical state of affairs.

However right here’s a query you’re in all probability questioning: what precisely are we alleged to do on this Catholic Dumbledore’s Military? What are we alleged to study and apply?

Nice questions! Now, Harry Potter and his buddies spent most of their time studying spells and potions they used to battle Voldemort. However clearly, we’re not witches and wizards. We don’t want spells and potions. So what do we have to study with a purpose to face our massive challenges, as Catholics?

Nicely, to reply that, let me take you again to my very own conversion to Catholicism. Keep in mind, I used to be in school once I turned Catholic, and I used to be a brand new convert making an attempt to determine issues out.

Each new matter I found, from the Eucharist, to Mary, to the saints, to the priesthood was like opening a brand new door to an enormous new room, lined with much more doorways! There was simply a lot to discover.

However even after changing, there have been nonetheless tons of questions and challenges I simply wasn’t prepared for. For instance, my associates would confront me with one thing like, “You already know the Catholic Church doesn’t like homosexual individuals, proper?” or “You understand Catholicism doesn’t respect ladies?” or “Why do you want God when science explains every little thing?”

To be trustworthy, I simply didn’t know what to say to most of these challenges. I used to be tongue-tied.

However I needed to get higher. So I began studying books. I learn and skim and skim. In reality, I learn at the very least 50 Catholic books across the time of my conversion. I learn apologetics books by Scott Hahn and Peter Kreeft, I learn religious books by the good saints, I learn theology and philosophy books, I simply absorbed as a lot I might.

On prime of that, I spent hours and hours studying articles on Catholic web sites and blogs and interacting within the remark packing containers. I might ask questions, throw out objections, bounce concepts off different Catholics, and simply learn, learn, learn as a lot as attainable.

However right here’s the factor: I shortly turned overwhelmed. I used to be taking in a lot info, and I used to be hardly remembering any of it.

You understand what that’s like, proper? I’m positive you do. You learn a very good e-book and really feel so robust and inspired, however then a number of days later, once you attempt to speak concerning the guide out loud with somebody, whenever you attempt to articulate what you learn, you mumble out some confused phrases and understand hardly any of the concepts caught in your thoughts! You recognize what that’s like?

Properly, that’s precisely what occurred to me. I used to be studying a lot however little or no of it was truly taking root. So I knew one thing needed to change.

And that’s once I had my subsequent massive epiphany. It got here whereas studying St. Thomas Aquinas.

Now, discovering Aquinas was a game-changer for me, in all types of the way. He simply completely modified my life. I can’t keep in mind how I first got here throughout Aquinas. I feel I stored seeing his identify popping up within the books I used to be studying.

However in any case, I did what many individuals do once they first study Aquinas and need to research him: I discovered his most well-known e-book, which is his Summa Theologiae.

Now it’s not a simple e-book to learn. It’s very dense and heavy, particularly when you come to it with no background in philosophy or theology, which I didn’t have. It’s additionally only a very lengthy ebook: in the preferred version, the Summa spans 5 books and over three,000 pages

So once I first opened the Summa, I barely understood any of it. Nevertheless, an enormous mild bulb nonetheless went off in my head. I wasn’t a lot struck by what Aquinas was saying within the Summa—that got here a lot later, as soon as I started to truly perceive it. My huge epiphany needed to do together with his type—that’s what initially hit me.

The Summa is principally a set of brief articles—there’s round three,000 articles—and every article wrestles with one troublesome query. So it’s sort of like an enormous Q&A with three,000 questions, or for those who’re a accustomed to Reddit, a really lengthy #AMA (Ask My Something.) No query is off limits for St. Thomas.

Each article within the Summa follows the identical format. Aquinas begins every article by posing a controversial query—corresponding to “Does God exist?” or “Was the soul made earlier than the physique?”

Then, Thomas instantly lists out a couple of of one of the best objections to his personal place. Actually, he often phrases the objections so properly, that he states them extra forcefully than his opponents do. In different phrases, he understands the objections even higher than the individuals who truly consider the objections!

Then, after itemizing the objections, he briefly explains and defends his personal view, the Catholic view, which stands towards all of the objections.

Lastly, he comes again to the objections themselves and punctiliously refutes them, one after one other.

In order that’s the rhythm. Thomas follows that fashion time and again, one query after one other, for all three,000 pages of the Summa—first the query, then the objections, then his view, then a response to the objections.

Now as I stated, even earlier than I understood a lot of the Summa, this format gave me an epiphany. I noticed that to be able to turn into a robust Catholic like Thomas Aquinas, or to modify again to our Harry Potter analogy, with a purpose to turn into a robust member of Dumbledore’s Military, I simply wanted to comply with that sample.

So as to be assured and clear concerning the hardest questions, I actually I didn’t have to learn dozens and dozens of books or spend a whole lot of hours studying articles and listening to podcasts.

All I actually wanted to know have been these three issues: First, the Catholic view of every matter. Second, one of the best objections to the Catholic view. And third, tips on how to reply these prime objections.

That’s it! That’s the key. That’s what made Thomas Aquinas so efficient and his Summa Theologiae one of the highly effective and enduring Catholic books in historical past.

Once more, to be a robust and assured Catholic, somebody who’s not afraid to debate your religion with family and friends, you solely have to memorize three issues: the Catholic view on every problem, the highest objections to the Catholic view, and the way to answer these objections. That’s it! These are the one three issues.

When you’re clear about these three issues—what you consider, the most effective objections to these beliefs, and methods to reply these objections—you’re outfitted and assured. You then’re prepared for the battle.

Then you’ll be able to stroll into virtually any state of affairs, whether or not a dialog together with your youngsters, or a problem from associates or co-workers, and know that you simply gained’t be nervous, you gained’t be afraid, and also you gained’t be tongue-tied. You’ll be assured, since you’re completely clear about what to say and the right way to act.

Once more, this is identical sample Harry Potter’s associates discovered via Dumbledore’s Military. Harry helped his pals get assured by educating them three issues: first, crucial good spells; second, an important dangerous spells, or curses, that the opposite aspect would attempt towards them; and third, the way to defeat or counter these curses. That’s it!

That is what gave Harry Potter and his associates a lot confidence once they confronted Voldemort and his darkish wizards. The scholars had already practiced countering most of the darkish spells of their Dumbledore’s Military periods, in order that they knew what to anticipate when dealing with precise darkish wizards.

In order that’s the sample. Study these three issues, and also you’re prepared for the battle. You’ll be assured and highly effective.

Now, I do know what you may be considering: “OK, that’s nice, however I’m simply not sensible sufficient to study all that. I imply, I’m no Pope Benedict or Scott Hahn. I’m only a easy, trustworthy Catholic.” However right here’s the factor: one of many largest myths about turning into a assured Catholic is that it’s tied on to your intelligence or IQ. However it’s not; that’s a lie.

In reality, a few of the best Catholics I’ve ever met are simply regular individuals. They don’t have superior levels. They haven’t learn tons of of books. They don’t have extraordinary IQs. However what they do have is mastery of some easy rules, they usually have readability about these three issues—what they consider, the most effective objections, and tips on how to reply.

So don’t assume you could be a world-class genius. In case you can memorize just some key concepts and techniques, which nearly everybody can do, you’ll be able to grasp these things.

Right here’s one other factor you may be considering: “Hey, I like this Harry Potter/Thomas Aquinas technique, however the issue is my reminiscence is so dangerous. I overlook most of what I learn or study.”

Now, I get that. It’s a standard objection. However know this: the primary cause we overlook most of what we study is that we absorb an excessive amount of info. It’s like consuming from a firehose. The knowledge is simply gushing into our heads and it’s robust to retain any of it.

However if you cease making an attempt to recollect 100 information or insights or methods, and as an alternative break them right down to the three most essential issues you should keep in mind, it out of the blue turns into straightforward.

Take into consideration Harry Potter once more. The scholars in Dumbledore’s Military didn’t attempt to memorize each single spell in your complete Hogwarts library. They mastered a number of key spells, a couple of key counters, and that’s all of the wanted.

Once more, keep in mind, to be a robust Catholic, there are solely three issues you should memorize for every difficulty: what you consider, one of the best objections to these beliefs, and methods to reply these objections.

Right here’s yet one more query you could be questioning: “That sounds nice, however gained’t it take a very long time to study these things?”

I imply take into consideration all the problems you would like you possibly can grasp, as a Catholic: atheism, same-sex marriage, transgenderism, abortion, the Bible, the Eucharist, and extra. Gained’t it take a very long time to study all three issues for every matter—what you consider, the most effective objections, and easy methods to reply? Gained’t it take hours and hours of research, memorization, and follow?

Nicely, I’m completely satisfied to inform you no, it gained’t take that lengthy. The truth is, it’s potential to study all these things in simply 15 minutes per week. And that’s precisely what you’ll uncover within the subsequent video, Video #four. So keep tuned for that in a number of days.

However within the meantime, earlier than we go at present, I would like you to go away a remark proper under this video and inform me this: How would your life be totally different for those who have been 100% assured about all these hot-button points?

Image it. Describe it for me. Inform me how you’d work together with associates or household in another way for those who have been 100% assured about these three issues—your beliefs, one of the best objections, and the way to answer these objections.

Now once more, I’m going to learn each single remark right here, and I’ll reply to as many as I can.

Additionally, please do me a favor: after you allow your remark, please share this hyperlink on Fb, Twitter, and even by emailing this URL to your folks. Simply click on one of many share buttons under or copy-and-paste the URL up prime.

Ship this video to fellow parishioners, mother and father, your priest! I’m so enthusiastic about this Catholic Dumbledore’s Military motion, and I need to attract as many Catholics as potential.

Lastly, yet one more factor, remember to click on the large button on this web page that claims, “Ship me Video #four” and pop in your identify and e mail. That means, I’ll e-mail you as quickly as Video #four is reside in a pair days.

Once more, thanks a lot for watching this video collection, and I’ll see you in a pair days within the subsequent video, Video #four!

var fbds = doc.createElement(‘script’);
fbds.async = true;
fbds.src = ‘//join.fb.internet/en_US/fbds.js’;
var s = doc.getElementsByTagName(‘script’)[0];
s.parentNode.insertBefore(fbds, s);
_fbq.loaded = true;

_fbq.push([‘addPixelId’, ‘1544344019154601’]);
window._fbq = window._fbq || [];
window._fbq.push([‘track’, ‘PixelInitialized’, ]);

About the author